Why Does My Banana Bread Taste Bland? | Plus How to Prevent It

It’s frustrating to spend a lot of time in your kitchen baking your banana bread, only to have it taste bland once it’s don

There are a number reasons why banana bread taste bland including using under ripe bananas, not putting salt in the mix, adding too much flour or overmixing the batter.

This article will explore the top 5 reasons why banana bread taste bland and how to fix it.

5 Reasons Why Banana Bread Taste Bland

Banana bread that doesn’t taste nice and sweet is what you want, but if you don’t get it, here are some of the reasons why.

1. The Bananas Were Underripe

The riper bananas are, the sweeter they become. If you’re not sure how to pick your bananas, look for fruit that is extremely soft and squishy and is just about to turn black

 Most of the peel should be brown, but make sure there are no fruit flies or any sign of mold.

Bananas that are still green will not give as much flavor to your banana bread as ripe ones.
Bananas that have brown on their skin will be flavorful and easy to mash into banana bread.

2. You Forgot the Salt

People do forget to add salt to their recipe for banana bread, and while very little salt is usually added when making bread, it is still a very important ingredient.

Never forget to add salt to your banana bread if you want it to come out tasty. It helps to enhance the flavor of the banana making.

3. Too much flour

Your flour-to-banana ratio is important when making banana bread. When you measure your flour, make sure you scoop the flour into a measuring cup, then use the side of a knife to level it off at the top.

If you use too much flour, or even too little, it can affect both the taste and texture of the bread.

Measure the flour exactly when making banana bread.

4. Overmixing the Batter

If you stir your banana bread batter too much, it creates too much gluten and you get a texture and taste that is rubbery and tough. Pay close attention to the instructions in the recipe, and only stir the ingredients until the batter is moist and no more.

Mix the banana bread batter until it is just combined.

5. Not Following the Directions

With every recipe, a set of instructions tells you exactly how to get your bread to come out just right. It’s crucial that you take your time with each step and make sure you follow the instructions to the letter every time. Otherwise, your banana bread will not come out right.

5 Ways to Make Banana Bread More Flavorful

Fortunately, there are simple and inexpensive ways to make your banana bread taste much better, and below are a few of them:

1. Add Bananas That Are Riper

Making sure your bananas are extra-ripe is crucial to getting the best-tasting banana bread. If the bananas are too firm, they won’t be very sweet, and they’ll also be much more difficult to mash up into the right texture. But most of all, riper bananas simply make sweeter banana bread.

2. Add Cinnamon or Nutmeg

You can add 1/4 teaspoon of either cinnamon or nutmeg – or 1/4 teaspoon of each – to your recipe for a sweeter flavor once the bread is baked. Don’t add any more than this amount or it’ll change the taste of the bread a little too much.

3. Use Brown Sugar

When you read the instructions and learn the amount of sugar required, try to replace about one-fourth of it with brown sugar instead of white. If it calls for one-half cup of sugar, use 1/8 to 1/4 cup of brown sugar and the rest white.

Check out this banana bread recipe full of flavor below.

4. Add Vanilla Extract

If you want a little more flavor in your banana bread, you can add one teaspoon of vanilla to your recipe. It’s best not to add more than that or it’s possible the bread will be too sweet when you’re done.

5. Add Other Unique Items

There are a lot of items you can add to banana bread that give it more flavor, even if they’re not mentioned in any recipe. For more unique options, try adding things such as chocolate chips, nuts, a little cocoa, orange zest, shredded zucchini, peanut butter, and even dried fruit.

These are just a few of the additions that will greatly improve the taste of your banana bread.

What Happens if You Put Too Much Banana in Banana Bread?

If you put too much banana in your banana bread, your bread might come out too damp, regardless of how long you bake it. It can turn damp and heavy especially in the center, which not only makes it undercooked but very unappealing as well.

For more on why banana bread stays soggy in the middle, check out this article: Banana Bread Still Gooey After an Hour? | Top 3 Causes and What to Do Next

Does Banana Bread Taste Better the Day After?

Most people agree that banana bread does indeed taste better the day after it is baked. This is partly because the moisture from the bananas tends to permeate the rest of the bread the longer it sits.

It is also because all of the other ingredients have had more of a chance to blend together, making for a much better overall flavor.

Can Bananas Be Too Ripe for Banana Bread?

Generally, the darker the bananas are, the better they are for your banana bread. You can let them sit for a few days to a week for brown bananas and up to eight weeks for black bananas.

The only bananas considered too ripe for banana bread are those bananas that have a funny smell or ones that are already starting to liquefy. If your bananas have a funny smell, always throw them in the trash and don’t use them in your banana bread.


There are numerous reasons why your banana bread may not have much flavor, but the biggest culprit is under-ripe bananas. Always make sure your bananas are at least turning brown and maybe even black before using them in your banana bread recipe. Other reasons exist but aren’t as important.